Above Suspicion (2021) is a crime thriller that dives deep into a true story of betrayal, deception, and murder, delivering a tense and gripping cinematic experience. Directed by Phillip Noyce, known for hits like Salt and Clear and Present Danger, this film brings a dark and compelling narrative to life, anchored by standout performances from Emilia Clarke and Jack Huston. Based on Joe Sharkey’s non-fiction book, Above Suspicion explores one of the most notorious crimes in FBI history, making it a must-watch for fans of true crime and thriller movies. This review delves into the film’s strengths, weaknesses, and why it’s worth your time.
What Is Above Suspicion About?
A True Crime Story of Betrayal
Set in the gritty backdrop of Pikeville, Kentucky, Above Suspicion follows Susan Smith (Emilia Clarke), a young woman trapped in a life of poverty, drug addiction, and domestic abuse. Living with her abusive ex-partner, Cash (Johnny Knoxville), in a rundown trailer, Susan sees a glimmer of hope when she meets Mark Putnam (Jack Huston), a newly minted FBI agent assigned to the area. Putnam recruits Susan as an informant for a high-profile case, but their professional relationship soon spirals into a dangerous illicit affair. As jealousy, deception, and violence take hold, the story builds to a shocking climax, resulting in the first-ever conviction of an FBI agent for murder.
A Tale of Desperation and Danger
The film, adapted by screenwriter Chris Gerolmo, uses Susan’s narrative voiceover from beyond the grave to frame the story, adding a haunting layer to the true crime drama. The Kentucky setting, with its stark depiction of a struggling coal-mining town, amplifies the sense of desperation and entrapment. Above Suspicion blends noir melodrama with psychological thriller elements, creating a narrative that’s both emotionally raw and suspenseful.
Strengths of Above Suspicion
Emilia Clarke’s Powerful Performance
Emilia Clarke, best known as Daenerys Targaryen in Game of Thrones, delivers a transformative performance as Susan Smith. Shedding her iconic fantasy role, Clarke embodies a troubled, naive, and desperate woman with a convincing Kentucky accent. Her portrayal is raw and gutsy, capturing Susan’s vulnerability and tragic arc. Critics have praised Clarke’s ability to carry the film, with her performance being a highlight in an otherwise uneven narrative.
A Strong Supporting Cast
The ensemble cast, including Jack Huston as the ambitious yet flawed FBI agent Mark Putnam, adds depth to the story. Huston’s portrayal of Putnam’s moral decline is compelling, though some reviews note his character lacks personality due to script limitations. Johnny Knoxville surprises as Cash, bringing a gritty authenticity to the role of Susan’s abusive ex. Supporting players like Thora Birch and Sophie Lowe shine in smaller roles, though their screen time is limited.
Atmospheric Direction by Phillip Noyce
Director Phillip Noyce brings a seasoned touch to Above Suspicion, creating a grim and moody atmosphere that suits the crime thriller genre. The film’s cinematography captures the bleakness of Pikeville, Kentucky, with its gray, somber visuals enhancing the story’s noir tone. While not as polished as Noyce’s bigger hits, his direction keeps the tension alive, particularly in scenes of violence and betrayal.
Weaknesses of Above Suspicion
Uneven Pacing and Script Issues
Despite its intriguing premise, Above Suspicion struggles with pacing, particularly in the middle, where the narrative drags. The screenplay by Chris Gerolmo has been criticized for focusing too much on salacious details and not enough on character development or the complexities of the true story. Some subplots, like the dynamics between Susan and Putnam’s wife, are underdeveloped, leaving potential drama unexplored.
Missed Opportunities in Storytelling
While the true crime story is inherently fascinating, the film doesn’t fully capture the depth of Pikeville’s setting or its characters, as the source book does. The Kentucky accents, while impressive from Clarke, feel inconsistent across the cast, and some characters, like FBI agent Singer, are underutilized. Critics note that the film feels more like a Lifetime thriller than a profound exploration of corruption and misogyny, leaving some viewers wanting more.
Why You Should Watch Above Suspicion
A Must for True Crime and Thriller Fans
If you’re a fan of true crime movies like The Undoing or Your Honor, Above Suspicion offers a compelling dive into a lesser-known but shocking FBI scandal. The film’s focus on betrayal, crime, and moral ambiguity makes it a gripping watch, even if it doesn’t fully live up to its potential. Emilia Clarke’s performance alone is worth the price of admission, showcasing her versatility as a dramatic actress.
A Tense and Entertaining Ride
Despite its flaws, Above Suspicion delivers enough suspense and drama to keep viewers engaged. The trailer promises intense moments of danger and deception, and the film largely delivers on that front. At 1 hour and 44 minutes, it’s a compact watch that’s perfect for a night of crime thriller entertainment.
Where to Watch Above Suspicion
Above Suspicion is available on streaming platforms like Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, and Fandango at Home. You can also rent or buy it on VOD services or purchase the DVD/Blu-ray. Check your preferred streaming service for availability in your region.
Final Thoughts on Above Suspicion
Above Suspicion (2021) is a gritty crime thriller that shines thanks to Emilia Clarke’s standout performance and Phillip Noyce’s atmospheric direction. While it doesn’t fully capture the depth of its true crime source material, the film offers enough suspense, betrayal, and drama to make it a worthwhile watch for fans of the genre. With a talented cast and a shocking real-life story, Above Suspicion is a solid, if flawed, addition to the thriller movie landscape. If you’re looking for a true crime tale with strong performances, this film is worth checking out.
Rating: 6.5/10
Stream Above Suspicion now and dive into a crime thriller that’s as haunting as it is entertaining.
